Review of André is an Idiot
A documentary that will make you laugh and cry.
André Is an Idiot is a documentary about dying that paradoxically has you laughing for the majority of it. Directed by Tony Benna, the documentary follows André Ricciardi, a Brooklyn ad executive diagnosed with stage IV colon cancer after ignoring the warning signs for some time and not getting a colonoscopy. Rather than wallow, André turns his own mortality into material, narrating his decline with a comedian's timing while also spreading awareness about the importance of colonoscopies for cancer screening.
André is abrasive, funny, occasionally cruel to himself and entirely unsentimental about his diagnosis until the moments when the facade cracks as he nears the end of his life. These sentimental moments hit harder because they're rare. They certainly made me fall apart, especially as we see how he physically changes. Andrés’ daughters and wife are also featured in the documentary, highlighting the emotional and sometimes physical toll that caring for someone with a terminal illness can take. The camera stays close throughout without becoming intrusive, letting silences and arguments breathe rather than manufacturing tearjerker beats.
Some viewers may find André's gallows humor exhausting before it becomes moving, but that's arguably the point: grief, comedy and life in general aren't tidy, and the documentary resists smoothing itself into a conventional cancer narrative. It's less interested in inspiring you than in being honest with you, which ends up being more affecting than any inspirational framing could manage.
By the end, what lingers isn't the diagnosis but the specificity of a person, his humor, his regrets, his love for his family, refusing to be reduced to an illness. While André does bring up how U.S. society is death averse and hates talking about it, he does shy away from showcasing his final wishes for himself. This could have been a privacy wish, or was just not thought of as important, but as someone who knows that not enough people plan ahead for their own death, I would love to have seen the importance of that planning highlighted not for him, but his family.
Definitely a must-watch and tissues are recommended.













